Taffy of the Month Club

Only $16.99/Month

with FREE shipping

Join the club and get an exclusive mix of Taffy Shop's gourmet saltwater taffy delivered to your door every month.

Each shipment includes two or more new flavors and over 50 total pieces of the freshest, most flavorful taffy you have ever tasted.

Get Started

Only $16.99/Month

with FREE shipping

Join the club and get an exclusive mix of Taffy Shop's gourmet saltwater taffy delivered to your door every month.

Each shipment includes two or more new flavors and over 50 total pieces of the freshest, most flavorful taffy you have ever tasted.

Get Started

December's Santa's Faves Mix

Enjoy Taffy of the Month Club's latest offering: The 'Santa's Faves' Mix featuring three new, EXCLUSIVE FLAVORS: Cinnamon Santas, Candy Canes, and Creamy Eggnog!

Always-On Perks

Taffy of the Month Club Membership has its privileges.
Beyond the amazingness of having taffy appear monthly, you'll get a handful of tasty benefits.

Free Shipping on All Orders

Taffy Club Members get FREE Shipping on every order! Really, every order? Yup. So, this order and any other orders placed on TaffyShop.com? Yup, you got it...free, free, free. 

Exclusive New Flavors

As a Taffy Club Member, you get access to exclusive new flavors in every monthly shipment. Includes a minimum of two never-before-released flavors just for our Members.

Quality Guarantee

If you don't have a great experience with your Taffy Club Membership or your taffy, we will make it right. End of story. 

World's Best Saltwater Taffy

Using top-quality ingredients, time-tested recipes, and a patented 24-Hour whipping process, we create the softest, creamiest, and most flavorful saltwater taffy anywhere.

How It Works

Every month we create a new custom saltwater taffy mix exclusively for Taffy Club Members. 
This includes at least one, but typically two (or even three) brand new flavors based on that month's theme.

1.

Start

Subscribe to the Taffy of the Month Club. Then the rest is easy. Actually subscribing is easy too, so what are you waiting for?

2.

Ship

When you finish, your order will process and get ready for shipping.  Each month you'll get a new custom mix with new flavors related to that month's theme. 

3.

Snack

You've joined. We've shipped. You've received. Now it's time to rip into your bag and enjoy your delicious gourmet salt water taffy.

Any Questions?

Here are answers to a few of the most common questions we get about the Taffy Club.

Fresh, Delicious, & Worry-Free

Amazing Taste &
Texture

  • Made in the USA
  • Premium Ingredients
  • Kettle Cooked
  • Small-Batch Mixing
  • True & Distinctive Flavoring
  • Resealable Bag for Freshness

Consumer-Conscious Manufacturing

  • Peanut-Free*
  • Tree Nut-Free*
  • Soy-Free
  • Gluten Free

*Includes the finished product and the manufacturing facility

Smiles All Around

We could tell you a lot about our taffy, but sometimes it's better to listen to what others have to say...

Katie S.

Delicious. Delectable. I grew up in NJ and always had Jersey Shore Salt Water Taffy - these are better.

Ellyn M.

I've tried several different brands (taffy is one of my favorite candies), and this was by far the best.

Jan K.

Absolutely fantastic. I can't believe how good these are. Fantastic service and candy. I will definitely shop here again.

Previous Mixes

Spice to Meet You

October 2022

Top of the Morning

September 2022

Wild West

August 2022

Ohana

July 2022

New Flavors

Gourmet Caramel, Pumpkin
Patch, Chocolate Orange

Classic Flavors

Candy Corn, Chocolate Caramel Latte, Pomegranate, Crisp Fall Apple

New Flavors

Breakfast Cereal,
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

Classic Flavors

Blueberry Muffin,
Cinnamon Roll, Maple Bacon

New Flavors

Prickly Pear,
Marizapan Peanut

Classic Flavors

Key Lime, Mexican
Vanilla, Chile Mango Madness

New Flavors

Chocolate Haupia,
POG (Passion, Orange, Guava)

Classic Flavors

Lillikoi (Passion Fruit),
Pineapple, Banana

See More

This site is not a part of the Facebook website or Facebook Inc. Additionally, this site is NOT endorsed by Facebook in any way. Facebook is a trademark of Facebook, Inc.