HOLIDAYS EXCLUSIVE: Add products to unlock rewards
Add $30.00 more to get
FREE SHIPPING +

FREE
SHIPPING

.

FREE
SHIPPING

15%
OFF

20%
OFF

25%
OFF

30%
OFF
5.0
Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy features creamy white saltwater taffy in a fun island motif; a chewy, classic treat | Taffy Shop.

Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy

(Vanilla Waffle Cone)

From $12.49
Vanilla Waffle Cone
4.4
Expresso Yourselfo Taffy in a classic brown mix of saltwater taffy, offering a chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop

Expresso Yourselfo Taffy

(Espresso + Cream + Vanilla + Caramel)

From $12.49
Espresso
Cream
Vanilla
Caramel
4.8
Bag of It's Pronounced Caramel Taffy with creamy saltwater taffy pieces, a classic chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop.

It's Pronounced Caramel Taffy

(Caramel + Vanilla)

From $12.49
Caramel
Vanilla
Pep in Your Step Taffy in a colorful mix of individually wrapped pieces, perfect classic treat saltwater taffy. | Taffy Shop

Pep in Your Step Taffy

(Pepper Pop + Coconut + Vanilla)

From $12.49
Pepper Pop
Coconut
Vanilla
2.5
Superman's Playdough Taffy features colorful saltwater taffy, a chewy candy delight perfect for classic treat lovers | Taffy Shop.

Superman's Playdough Taffy

(Lemon+ Vanilla Pudding + Raspberry)

From $12.49
Lemon
Vanilla Pudding
Raspberry

Classic Flavors

View all

4.9
It's B-A-N-A-N-A-S Taffy featuring yellow and white chewy candy pieces, a classic treat in salt water taffy style. | Taffy Shop

It's B-A-N-A-N-A-S Taffy

(Banana)

From $12.49
Banana
5.0
Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy features creamy white saltwater taffy in a fun island motif; a chewy, classic treat | Taffy Shop.

Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy

(Vanilla Waffle Cone)

From $12.49
Vanilla Waffle Cone
5.0
Cinniminni Taffy presents a colorful assortment of chewy saltwater taffy in a playful mix of flavors and colors | Taffy Shop.

Cinniminni Taffy

(Cinnamon)

From $12.49
Cinnamon
4.7
Mint for Each Other Taffy features pastel mint-green saltwater taffy, a chewy candy classic treat in a resealable bag | Taffy Shop

Mint for Each Other Taffy

(Peppermint)

From $12.49
Peppermint
4.7
What-the-Melon Taffy saltwater taffy in bright green and pink packaging, offering a juicy watermelon flavor | Taffy Shop

What-the-Melon Taffy

(Watermelon)

From $12.49
Watermelon
5.0
Suspicious Licorices Taffy features chewy salt water taffy in bold black and red swirls classic treat | Taffy Shop

Suspicious Licorices Taffy

(Black Licorice)

From $12.49
Black Licorice
5.0
Strawesome Taffy in vibrant, colorful packaging offers a variety of chewy saltwater taffy flavors. | Taffy Shop

Strawesome Taffy

(Strawberry)

From $12.49
Strawberry
5.0
Birthday Cake Cake Taffy features colorful, chewy saltwater taffy in a festive bag, ideal for any celebration | Taffy Shop

Birthday Cake Cake Taffy

(Birthday Cake)

From $12.49
Birthday Cake

Fusion Flavors

View all

4.4
Expresso Yourselfo Taffy in a classic brown mix of saltwater taffy, offering a chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop

Expresso Yourselfo Taffy

(Espresso + Cream + Vanilla + Caramel)

From $12.49
Espresso
Cream
Vanilla
Caramel
4.4
How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy bag filled with apple-flavored saltwater taffy, a classic chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop

How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy

(Caramel + Apple + Sea Salt)

From $12.49
Caramel
Apple
Sea Salt
5.0
Fo' Sizzle My Drizzle Taffy in a colorful bag showcasing delicious saltwater taffy candies, a chewy candy delight | Taffy Shop

Fo' Sizzle My Drizzle Taffy

(Maple + Bacon + Pecan)

From $12.49
Maple
Bacon
Pecan
4.8
CocoCabana Taffy features colorful saltwater taffy pieces in fun flavors, a chewy candy classic treat. | Taffy Shop

CocoCabana Taffy

(Coconut+ Passion Fruit + Mango + Lime)

From $12.49
Coconut
Passion Fruit
Mango
Lime
4.7
Funky Monkey Taffy salt water taffy package displaying vibrant colors highlights this classic chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop

Funky Monkey Taffy

(Banana+ Coconut+ Rum)

From $12.49
Banana
Coconut
Rum
4.7
North Shore Taffy pack with an assortment of colorful salt water taffy, a classic treat for all ages | Taffy Shop

North Shore Taffy

(Fruit Punch)

From $12.49
Fruit Punch
4.3
The Red, White, & Chew Taffy features a vibrant mix of red, white, and blue saltwater taffy, a classic chewy candy. | Taffy Shop

Red, White, & Chew Taffy

(Cherry + Lime + Raspberry)

From $12.49
Cherry
Lime
Raspberry
3.5
Pumpy McPumpkin Face Taffy bag displaying cheerful packaging of orange and black salt water taffy for a Halloween treat | Taffy Shop

Pumpy McPumpkin Face Taffy

(Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie)

From $12.49
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie

Sour Zappy Flavors

View all

5.0
The Sour Cherry Limeade Zappy Taffy showcases vibrant colorful packaging highlighting its saltwater taffy flavor. | Taffy Shop

Sour Cherry Limeade Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Cherry
Limeade
5.0
Sour Cranberry Apple Zappy Taffy features a vibrant red, green mix of salt water taffy | Taffy Shop.

Sour Cranberry Apple Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Cranberry
Apple
Sour Fruit Punch Zappy Taffy, vibrant packaging and vivid colors, a chewy candy delight perfect for sweet cravings | Taffy Shop

Sour Fruit Punch Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Fruit Punch
5.0
Sour Grapefruit Blueberry Zappy Taffy features colorful saltwater taffy candies in a playful mix, perfect as chewy candy treats | Taffy Shop.

Sour Grapefruit Blueberry Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Grape
Blueberry
Sour Lime Rickey Zappy Taffy, a vibrant green chewable saltwater taffy, offers a refreshing citrus flavor | Taffy Shop.

Sour Lime Rickey Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Lime
Grape
Packaging of Sour Pineapple Passion Fruit Zappy Taffy shows a vibrant, chewy saltwater taffy, perfect for candy lovers | Taffy Shop.

Sour Pineapple Passion Fruit Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Pineapple
Passion Fruit
5.0
Sour Raspberry Lemonade Zappy Taffy features vibrant pink and yellow saltwater taffy, a chewy candy delight | Taffy Shop.

Sour Raspberry Lemonade Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Raspberry
Lemonade
5.0
Sour Strawberry Banana Zappy Taffy with vibrant packaging promises a chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop.

Sour Strawberry Banana Zappy Taffy

From $12.49
Strawberry
Banana

Sugar-Free Flavors

4.8
Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Taffy in beige packaging, chewy candy, classic saltwater taffy flavor | Taffy Shop

Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Taffy

From $13.99
Vanilla
4.6
Sugar-Free Banana Dream Taffy in colorful packaging, showcasing delicious chewy saltwater taffy flavor | Taffy Shop

Sugar-Free Banana Dream Taffy

From $13.99
Banana
4.6
Sugar-Free Cinnamon Taffy is a chewy saltwater taffy in spicy cinnamon flavor, ideal classic treat. | Taffy Shop

Sugar-Free Cinnamon Taffy

From $13.99
Cinnamon
5.0
Sugar-Free Whipped Chocolate Taffy features a rich, dark color offering a guilt-free, chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop.

Sugar-Free Whipped Chocolate Taffy

From $13.99
Chocolate
Sugar-Free Fresh Strawberry Taffy in vibrant red candy-striped packaging, a chewy saltwater taffy delight | Taffy Shop

Sugar-Free Fresh Strawberry Taffy

From $13.99
Strawberry
5.0
Sugar-Free Rad Raspberry Taffy with vibrant pink wrapper showcases chewy classic saltwater taffy delight | Taffy Shop.

Sugar-Free Rad Raspberry Taffy

From $13.99
Raspberry