Novelty Taffy Candy

Sort by

View as

Build-A-Mix Custom Taffy (32oz) Taffy Shop

$23.49 - $23.49

$23.49

$23.49 - $23.49

$23.49

Build-A-Mix Custom Taffy (32oz)

Bring home a treat that everyone will love with our Build-A-Mix Family Size bag. Packed with 32 ounces of our freshest saltwater taffy, you have th...

View full details

$23.49 - $23.49

$23.49

$23.49 - $23.49

$23.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Chew-bal-cca Taffy

Flavor: Balsalmic + Berry + Dark Chocolate

In stock

Indulge in the sophisticated blend of balsamic notes, juicy berries, and rich dark chocolate with our Chew-bal-cca Saltwater Taffy. This gourmet ca...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Chew-La-La Taffy

Flavor: Peach + Orange + Cranberry

In stock

Delight in the harmonious fusion of succulent peach, vibrant orange, and tangy cranberry with our Chew-La-La Saltwater Taffy. Each bite offers a bu...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Choco Coco Loco Taffy

Flavor: Chocolate + Coconut + Caramel

In stock

Experience the ultimate trio of smooth chocolate, creamy coconut, and luscious caramel in our Choco Coco Loco Saltwater Taffy. This decadent candy ...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

CocoCabana Taffy

Flavor: Coconut + Passion Fruit + Mango + Lime

In stock

Transport yourself to a tropical paradise with CocoCabana Saltwater Taffy, featuring an exotic mix of coconut, passion fruit, mango, and a hint of ...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Expresso Yourselfo Taffy

Flavor: Espresso + Cream + Vanilla + Caramel

In stock

Energize your senses with Expresso Yourselfo Saltwater Taffy, blending robust espresso, velvety cream, rich vanilla, and sweet caramel. This delici...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Feel the Beet Taffy

Flavor: Beetroot + Lemonade

In stock

Embrace the earthy sweetness of beetroot paired with zesty lemonade in our Feel the Beet Saltwater Taffy. This unique candy combines vibrant flavor...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Fo' Sizzle My Drizzle Taffy

Flavor: Maple + Bacon + Pecan

In stock

Indulge in the savory-sweet sensation of Fo' Sizzle My Drizzle Saltwater Taffy, featuring rich maple, smoky bacon, and crunchy pecans. This inventi...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Funky Monkey Taffy

Flavor: Banana + Coconut + Rum

In stock

Enjoy a tropical escape with Funky Monkey Saltwater Taffy, blending ripe banana, creamy coconut, and a splash of rum. This playful candy delivers a...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

G.O.A.T. Taffy

Flavor: Ginger + Orange + Apricot + Turmeric

In stock

Discover the extraordinary with G.O.A.T. Saltwater Taffy, a powerful mix of spicy ginger, tangy orange, sweet apricot, and earthy turmeric. This bo...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Gimme S'more Taffy

Flavor: Graham Cracker + Chocolate + Marshmallow

Out of stock

Relive campfire fun with Gimme S'more Saltwater Taffy, combining crunchy graham cracker, rich chocolate, and gooey marshmallow flavors. This nostal...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Sold out

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Grandma Hazel is a Nut Taffy

Flavor: Chocolate + Hazelnut + Raspberry + Cream Cheese

In stock

Indulge in the nutty delight of Grandma Hazel is a Nut Saltwater Taffy, featuring decadent chocolate, roasted hazelnuts, tangy red raspberry, and c...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Have a Peek at This Chew Taffy Taffy Shop

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Have a Peek at This Chew Taffy

Flavor: Ramune (Lemon + Lime + Bubblegum)

In stock

Refresh your palate with Have a Peek at This Chew Saltwater Taffy, a playful mix of zesty lemon, bright lime, and sweet bubblegum. This lively cand...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Hipsters in Paradise Taffy

Flavor: Grapefruit + Basil + Mint

In stock

Savor the sophisticated flavors of Hipsters in Paradise Saltwater Taffy, blending tart grapefruit with aromatic basil and cooling mint. This trendy...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy Taffy Shop

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy

Flavor: Caramel + Apple + Sea Salt

In stock

Indulge in the classic taste of How Do You Like Them Apples? Saltwater Taffy, featuring luscious salted caramel and crisp apple. This candy combine...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Machew Pichew Taffy

Flavor: Cream Soda + Bubble Gum + Champagne

In stock

Celebrate with Machew Pichew Saltwater Taffy, a sparkling blend of creamy soda, sweet bubblegum, and effervescent champagne. This festive candy off...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Mingo Mango Mongo Taffy

Flavor: Chili + Mango + Lime

In stock

Ignite your taste buds with Mingo Mango Mongo Saltwater Taffy, combining juicy mango, spicy chili, and tangy lime. This vibrant candy delivers a sw...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Norm's Hot Honey Taffy

Flavor: Hot Sauce + Honey

In stock

Spice up your sweet moments with Norm's Hot Honey Saltwater Taffy, blending smooth honey with a fiery hot sauce kick. This unique candy offers a ta...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

North Shore Taffy

Flavor: Fruit Punch

In stock

Dive into the vibrant flavors of North Shore Saltwater Taffy, featuring a classic fruit punch blend. This colorful candy delivers a medley of fruit...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

O.G. P.O.G. Taffy

Flavor: Passion + Orange + Guava

In stock

Enjoy the timeless flavors of O.G. P.O.G. Saltwater Taffy, a nostalgic blend of passionfruit, orange, and guava. This classic candy offers a fruity...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

People's PPL Taffy

Flavor: Pomegranate + Peach + Lemonade

In stock

Savor the rich combination of pomegranate, juicy peach, and refreshing lemonade in People's PPL Saltwater Taffy. This vibrant candy offers a sweet ...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Pep in Your Step Taffy

Flavor: Pepper Pop + Coconut + Vanilla

In stock

Energize your day with Pep in Your Step Saltwater Taffy, a dynamic mix of pepper pop, creamy coconut, and smooth vanilla. This lively candy deliver...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Pterodactyl Ptaffy Taffy

Flavor: Breakfast Cereal

In stock

Kickstart your mornings with Pterodactyl Ptaffy Salt Water Taffy, inspired by your favorite breakfast cereal. This nostalgic candy combines sweet a...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Pumpy McPumpkin Face Taffy

Flavor: Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie

In stock

Celebrate autumn with Pumpy McPumpkin Face Saltwater Taffy, blending pumpkin, chocolate chips, and cozy spices. This unique candy offers a sweet an...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Red, White, & Chew Taffy

Flavor: Cherry + Lime + Blue Raspberry

In stock

Enjoy the patriotic flavors of Red, White, & Chew Saltwater Taffy, combining ripe cherry, zesty lime, and tangy blue raspberry. This vibrant ca...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Rio de Taffineiro Taffy

Flavor: Guarana + Acai + Lime

In stock

Energize your senses with Rio de Taffineiro Salt Water Taffy, a bold blend of guarana, acai, and refreshing lime. This superfruit-inspired candy of...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Superman's Playdough Taffy

Flavor: Lemon + Vanilla Pudding + Red Raspberry

In stock

Unleash your inner hero with Superman's Playdough Saltwater Taffy, featuring tangy lemon, creamy vanilla pudding, and sweet raspberry. This playful...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Sweeto Mojito Taffy

Flavor: Rum + Lime + Mint

In stock

Refresh your palate with Sweeto Mojito Salt Water Taffy, blending smooth rum, zesty lime, and cooling mint. This cocktail-inspired candy offers a c...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

U.F.O. Taffy

Flavor: Mystery

In stock

Unlock the secrets of flavor with U.F.O. Salt Water Taffy’s Mystery Flavor. This unique candy offers a smooth and creamy chew that’s truly out of t...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Very Fire Berry Taffy

Flavor: Blueberry + Raspberry + Cayenne

In stock

Ignite your taste buds with Very Fire Berry Saltwater Taffy, combining sweet blueberry, tart raspberry, and a spicy kick of cayenne. This dynamic c...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Zen Master Taffy

Flavor: Lemon + Lavender + Chamomile

In stock

Find your calm with Zen Master Saltwater Taffy, a soothing blend of lemon, lavender, and chamomile. This tranquil candy offers a relaxing and chewy...

View full details

$7.49 - $21.49

$7.49

Novelty Taffy Candy: A Taste of Whimsy and Nostalgia

Why Choose Taffy Shop’s Novelty Taffy?

At Taffy Shop, we want candy to be a delightful and delicious experience. That’s why our novelty taffy is whipped—not pulled—for a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture you won’t find anywhere else. Each piece offers a vibrant and colorful flavor adventure, taking you on quirky twists that will surprise and satisfy your tastebuds.

If you’re searching for a quirky gift for someone special, a nostalgic snack, or just a little something to brighten your day, you’re at the right place! Our novelty candy is here to add a touch of whimsy to your life.

What Makes Our Taffy Unique? Great Question!

Whipped to Perfection: Unlike regular taffy, ours is whipped for a smooth, satisfying texture.
Bold, Unforgettable Flavors: From the tangy zing of Pickle to the sweet fantasy of Unicorn Poop, our flavors are as fun as they are unique.
Gluten-Free Goodness: Made for everyone to enjoy, our taffy is gluten-free. That way, no one has to miss out on the fun.

Our Featured Flavors

Dill Pickle Taffy Bag: A bold blend of sweet and sour that transforms an everyday snack into an unforgettable adventure. Who knew pickles could taste this good?
Unicorn Poop Taffy Bag: Step into a fantastical world with cake batter-flavored taffy. It’s a fun, magical treat that’s like biting into a fairytale.
Hipsters in Paradise Taffy: A trendy mix of tart grapefruit, fragrant basil, and cool mint. Perfect for those with a modern, adventurous palate.

How to Enjoy Our Novelty Taffy Candy

Mix and Match: Pair different flavors to create a custom candy experience that’s as fun as it is delicious.
Candy Buffets: Bring a smile to everyone’s faces at events, parties, or weddings by featuring our colorful taffy in a candy buffet.
Gift Giving: Surprise friends, family, or coworkers with a unique treat they’ll love and remember.
On-the-Go Treats: Pack a few pieces in your bag for an on-the-go snack that’s full of personality and flavor.
Celebration Favors: Use novelty taffy as a fun and memorable addition to party favors or holiday stockings.

If you’re looking for guilt-free options, look no further. You can explore our sugar-free taffy candy collection. Got a craving for something fruity instead? Don’t miss our raspberry taffy candy.

Frequently Asked Questions About Novelty Taffy Candy

What makes novelty taffy different?

Our vibrant novelty candy infuses unexpected flavors for a magical candy experience like no other. Its soft texture makes it the perfect candy to enjoy when celebrating, gifting, or simply indulging in a unique treat.

Is novelty taffy gluten-free?

Yes! All Taffy Shop products, including our novelty taffy candy, are gluten-free.

How long does novelty taffy stay fresh?

When stored in a cool, dry place, our novelty taffy stays fresh for months, ensuring you can enjoy its delightful flavors at your own pace.

Can I order novelty taffy in bulk for events?

Absolutely! Bulk orders are ideal for candy buffets, party favors, and stocking up on your favorite flavors.

Explore More From Taffy Shop

Sprinkle some magic into your life with Taffy Shop’s novelty taffy candy collection! Our taffy is the perfect nostalgic treat or a great quirky gift. Our collection is here to satisfy your sweet tooth in the most playful way.

Filters

Novelty Taffy Candy: A Taste of Whimsy and Nostalgia

Why Choose Taffy Shop’s Novelty Taffy?

What Makes Our Taffy Unique? Great Question!

Our Featured Flavors

How to Enjoy Our Novelty Taffy Candy

Frequently Asked Questions About Novelty Taffy Candy

What makes novelty taffy different?

Is novelty taffy gluten-free?

How long does novelty taffy stay fresh?

Can I order novelty taffy in bulk for events?

Explore More From Taffy Shop