Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S.

Best Sellers Collection (Rebuy)

Filters

Classic Favorites Taffy Mix Taffy Shop Personal (7oz)
Classic Favorites Taffy Mix Taffy Shop Sold out
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49

Classic Favorites Taffy Mix

Out of stock

The Classic Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix features an irresistible variety of our top-selling Classic flavors like: Cherr Up! (cherry), Grape Esca...

View full details
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49
Sold out
Unicorn Poop Taffy Bag (7oz) Taffy Shop
Unicorn Poop Taffy Bag (7oz) Taffy Shop
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49

Unicorn Poop Taffy Bag (7oz)

In stock

Delight in the whimsical magic of our Unicorn Poop Taffy Bag, featuring delicious and creamy Cake Batter Salt Water taffy. This unique treat is per...

View full details
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
World's Best Salt Water Taffy Bag (7oz) Taffy Shop
Bestsellers 12-Pack Bundle Taffy Shop
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49

World's Best Salt Water Taffy Bag (7oz)

In stock

Get only the best with our World's Best Salt Water Taffy Bag. Featuring some of our best selling flavors: Fluff Stuff (cotton candy), Bohemian Rasp...

View full details
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49
$12.49 - $12.49
$12.49