HOLIDAYS EXCLUSIVE: Add products to unlock rewards
Add $30.00 more to get
FREE SHIPPING +

FREE
SHIPPING

.

FREE
SHIPPING

15%
OFF

20%
OFF

25%
OFF

30%
OFF
5.0
Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy features creamy white saltwater taffy in a fun island motif; a chewy, classic treat | Taffy Shop.

Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy

(Vanilla Waffle Cone)

From $12.49
Vanilla Waffle Cone
3.8
Expresso Yourselfo Taffy in a classic brown mix of saltwater taffy, offering a chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop

Expresso Yourselfo Taffy

(Espresso + Cream + Vanilla + Caramel)

From $12.49
Espresso
Cream
Vanilla
Caramel
4.6
Bag of It's Pronounced Caramel Taffy with creamy saltwater taffy pieces, a classic chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop.

It's Pronounced Caramel Taffy

(Caramel + Vanilla)

From $12.49
Caramel
Vanilla
4.8
Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Taffy in beige packaging, chewy candy, classic saltwater taffy flavor | Taffy Shop

Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Taffy

From $13.99
Vanilla
Pep in Your Step Taffy in a colorful mix of individually wrapped pieces, perfect classic treat saltwater taffy. | Taffy Shop

Pep in Your Step Taffy

(Pepper Pop + Coconut + Vanilla)

From $12.49
Pepper Pop
Coconut
Vanilla
2.5
Superman's Playdough Taffy features colorful saltwater taffy, a chewy candy delight perfect for classic treat lovers | Taffy Shop.

Superman's Playdough Taffy

(Lemon+ Vanilla Pudding + Raspberry)

From $12.49
Lemon
Vanilla Pudding
Raspberry

Fall Favorites

5.0
The Voodoo Taffy Bag (7oz) features colorful, assorted saltwater taffy perfect for chewy candy lovers | Taffy Shop.

Voodoo Taffy Bag (7oz)

$12.49
4.4
How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy bag filled with apple-flavored saltwater taffy, a classic chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop

How Do You Like Them Apples? Taffy

(Caramel + Apple + Sea Salt)

From $12.49
Caramel
Apple
Sea Salt
3.8
Expresso Yourselfo Taffy in a classic brown mix of saltwater taffy, offering a chewy candy experience | Taffy Shop

Expresso Yourselfo Taffy

(Espresso + Cream + Vanilla + Caramel)

From $12.49
Espresso
Cream
Vanilla
Caramel
4.5
Fall Favorites Taffy Mix showcases colorful salt water taffy, embodying a classic treat for autumn enjoyment | Taffy Shop.

Fall Favorites Taffy Mix

From $12.49
3.5
Pumpy McPumpkin Face Taffy bag displaying cheerful packaging of orange and black salt water taffy for a Halloween treat | Taffy Shop

Pumpy McPumpkin Face Taffy

(Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie)

From $12.49
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie
5.0
Moose Snax Taffy Bag (7oz) features colorful, assorted saltwater taffy pieces, offering a chewy candy treat | Taffy Shop.

Moose Snax Taffy Bag (7oz)

$12.49