Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S.
Favorites 12-Pack Bundle Taffy Shop

Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy

Flavor: Vanilla Waffle Cone

$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49
Size: Personal (7oz)
Stock Up and Save Banner

Indulge in the creamy, smooth taste of our Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Salt Water Taffy. Offering a simple yet sophisticated vanilla flavor, this taffy is always a favorite. Its rich, buttery notes and chewy texture create a timeless candy experience that delights vanilla lovers with every bite.

No Peanuts, No Gluten, No Soy. Contains Milk, Egg Whites, and Tree Nuts (Coconut Oil). Made in the USA.

  • Approx. 30 Pieces in the 7oz Personal Size Bag
  • Approx. 140 Pieces in the 32oz Family Size Bag
  • Individually Wrapped
  • Made Exclusively in the USA
  • Small Batch Kettle Cooked
  • Premium Flavoring and Ingredients
  • 24-Hour Conditioning Process
  • Resealable Bag for Freshness

As Seen On

The Taffy Shop Difference

Taffy Shop
Saltwater Taffy		 Laffy Taffy
Candy 		Hi-Chew
Candy		 Traditional
Saltwater Taffy
Made with Pure Coconut Oil Yes! No No No
Whipped for Softness Yes! No No No
Made with Real Sea Salt Yes! No No No
Family Owned & Operated Yes! No No No
Made with Real Egg Whites Yes! No No No

Tell Me More!

Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Taffy Taffy Shop

Vanilla Salt Water Taffy

Flavor: Vanilla Waffle Cone

Enjoy the ultimate taste of nostalgia with Vanilla Salt Water Taffy! Creamy, dreamy, and melt-in-your-mouthy, each bite brings the sweet richness of vanilla bean, evoking memories of frosty cones on a sun-kissed boardwalk. A classic comfort in every chew—your perfect nostalgic treat!

How Many Pieces?

  • Approx. 30 Pieces in the 7oz Personal Size Bag
  • Approx. 140 Pieces in the 32oz Family Size Bag

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews
100%
(3)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
P
Pamela C.
Best Taffy Ever!

Now I am not a big fan of taffy. I grown up trying the salt water taffy sold here in New England and couldn't stand it. Well, I was throwing a party and was making some party favors and needed white candy. Someone suggested getting taffy. Well, I first ordered some through Amazon. Big mistake. Wasn't white like it was shown and taste was just ok. Then I came across this company and ordered a small trial bag after my last dud. Well, I wish I went here first cuz not only did it fit the whiteness needed for the favor it was the best taffy I've ever had. Not only is it a great tasting but the company was very efficient in getting the taffy delivered to me on time for the party. Highly recommend this place and trying the very vanilla taffy!

User picture
K
Kelli A.G.
Very very smooth

Best taffy that I have had since I left the shore.

H
Heidi

love! will order again!

Taffy Shop Saltwater Taffy FAQ

How Many Pieces of Taffy Come in Each Vanilla Candy Bag?

The majority of our products, including individual flavors and assortments, come in a variety of sizes. On average there are about 60 pieces of taffy per pound. Here are some of our specific bag sizes with an approximate number of pieces you can expect:

  • 7oz = 30 pieces
  • 32oz = 140 pieces
How Long Does It Take For My Order To Ship

Orders are shipped within 1-2 business days using standard shipping (3-5 days), with expedited options available.

Do You Offer Wholesale or Buik Ordering?

For wholesale or bulk taffy orders, please go to TaffyShopWholesale.com or call us at (801) 928-7080.

What Ingredients are Used in Your Original Saltwater Taffy?

Our Original Saltwater taffy includes: corn syrup, sugar, coconut oil, sea salt, egg whites, evaporated milk, cocoa, malic acid, citric acid, sunflower lecithin, titanium dioxide, natural and artificial flavor, artificial color (including FD&C blue 1, red 2, red 3, red 40, yellow 5, yellow 6).

How is Taffy Shop Saltwater Taffy Made?

To make the tastiest taffy imaginable we start with only the best ingredients, including proprietary flavor formulas from industry-leading flavor scientists (is that really their title? We're not 100% sure, but what we do know is their results are second-to-none). Then we utilize our patented 24-Hour whipping process to create the softest, lightest, fluffiest, and most consistent saltwater taffy you can buy.

Simply put, we want our taffy to taste just as soft and fresh for you as the day it was made.

Is Your Taffy Made With Soy, Nuts, Peanuts, or Tree Nuts? Does it Contain Gluten?

No! Taffy Shop Saltwater Taffy is completely free of soy, nuts, peanuts, tree nuts, and other nuts. It is also Gluten Free. So are our manufacturing facilities. Any of our taffy flavors that contains the word "nut," are made with flavoring only, NO ACTUAL NUTS of any kind.