Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S. FREE SHIPPING On All Orders Within Continental U.S.

Salt Water Taffy Flavors By Colors

Discover the vibrant world of saltwater taffy flavors by color at Taffy Shop. With 75+ unique flavors, our colorful taffy selection ensures there's a perfect match for every taste preference. Experience the delightful variety and nostalgic charm of our taffy today.

Filters

Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49

Rio de Taffineiro Taffy

Flavor: Guarana + Acai + Lime

In stock

Energize your senses with Rio de Taffineiro Salt Water Taffy, a bold blend of guarana, acai, and refreshing lime. This superfruit-inspired candy of...

View full details
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49

U.F.O. Taffy

Flavor: Mystery

In stock

Unlock the secrets of flavor with U.F.O. Salt Water Taffy’s Mystery Flavor. This unique candy offers a smooth and creamy chew that’s truly out of t...

View full details
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49

Pep in Your Step Taffy

Flavor: Pepper Pop + Coconut + Vanilla

In stock

Energize your day with Pep in Your Step Salt Water Taffy, a dynamic mix of pepper pop, creamy coconut, and smooth vanilla. This lively candy delive...

View full details
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49

Sweeto Mojito Taffy

Flavor: Rum + Lime + Mint

In stock

Refresh your palate with Sweeto Mojito Salt Water Taffy, blending smooth rum, zesty lime, and cooling mint. This cocktail-inspired candy offers a c...

View full details
Original price $12.49 - Original price $26.99
Original price
$12.49 - $26.99
$12.49 - $26.99
Current price $12.49

Explore Our Colorful Taffy Flavor

At Taffy Shop, we pride ourselves on offering a rainbow of taffy flavors to delight every palate. Whether you're searching for a specific color or eager to try something new, our extensive collection has got you covered.

How Many Flavors of Salt Water Taffy Are There?

With over 90 unique salt water taffy flavors, our selection is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. From classic favorites to innovative new tastes, there's something for everyone.

Popular Taffy Flavors by Color

Purple Taffy Flavor:

Grape Grape – A timeless favorite, our grape taffy is bursting with juicy flavor.

Yellow Taffy Flavor:

Banana Dream – Sweet and creamy, this flavor is a hit among all ages.

Blue Taffy Flavor:

Rad Raspberry – A tangy and sweet treat that's perfect for any occasion.

Pink and White Taffy Flavor:

Sweet Peppermint – Refreshingly minty, this taffy is a classic delight.

Green Taffy Flavor:

Granny Apple – Tart and sweet, this flavor brings a crisp, fruity taste.

What is the Most Popular Taffy Flavor?

While preferences vary, our customers often rave about the rich and buttery taste of our classic vanilla taffy. Its smooth, creamy texture makes it a standout favorite.

Frequently Asked Questions About Taffy

Is Taffy Just Toffee?

No, taffy and toffee are different candies. Taffy is a soft, chewy candy made by stretching or pulling a mixture of boiled sugar, butter, and flavorings. Toffee is a hard, brittle candy made by caramelizing sugar or molasses with butter.

Why is Taffy So Chewy?

The chewy texture of taffy comes from the process of pulling the candy, which aerates it and gives it its distinctive consistency.

What Was the First Flavor of Taffy?

The original flavor of taffy was likely molasses or vanilla, both classic flavors that have stood the test of time.

Why is it Called Salt Water Taffy?

Despite the name, salt water taffy doesn't contain seawater. The name originated in Atlantic City in the late 19th century, likely due to its seaside popularity.

What is the Difference Between Taffy and Salt Water Taffy?

There is no significant difference between taffy and salt water taffy. The terms are often used interchangeably, with "salt water" being a nostalgic nod to its coastal origins.

 

For more delightful flavors and gift ideas, explore our Taffy Shop Collections. Whether you're looking for a specific color or planning a themed event, our diverse selection ensures you'll find the perfect taffy for any occasion. Enjoy the sweet journey!