Skip to content

Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Candy

Hippity-hop your way into Taffy Shop’s delightful sugar-free Easter taffy candy collection! We craft each piece to bring you the softest, most melt-in-your-mouthest texture. We’re giving you delicious flavors you’ve come to know and love from us—minus the sugar. 

Filters

Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Favorites Taffy Mix

In stock

Discover the guilt-free pleasure of our Sugar-Free Favorites Salt Water Taffy Mix. Crafted to maintain the soft and chewy texture you love, this as...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Taffy

In stock

Experience the classic, creamy taste of vanilla in a healthier form with our Sugar-Free Very Vanilla Salt Water Taffy. This treat maintains the bel...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Whipped Chocolate Taffy

In stock

Indulge in the decadent taste of chocolate without the sugar with our Sugar-Free Whipped Chocolate Salt Water Taffy. Crafted for those managing the...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Banana Dream Taffy

In stock

Treat yourself guilt-free with our Sugar-Free Banana Dream Salt Water Taffy. This creamy, banana-flavored treat allows for a delightful indulgence ...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Cinnamon Taffy

In stock

Enjoy the spicy-sweet charm of cinnamon year-round with our Sugar-Free Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy. Perfect for those looking for guilt-free comforts...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Fresh Strawberry Taffy

In stock

Delight in the essence of ripe strawberries with our Sugar-Free Fresh Strawberry Salt Water Taffy. This healthier option offers all the sweetness w...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Rad Raspberry Taffy

In stock

Enjoy the vibrant raspberry flavor without the guilt with our Sugar-Free Rad Raspberry Salt Water Taffy. This sugar-free option offers a burst of s...

View full details
Original price $7.99 - Original price $23.49
Original price
$7.99 - $23.49
$7.99 - $23.49
Current price $7.99

Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Candy: Sweet Without the Sugar

Why Choose Taffy Shop’s Sugar-Free Taffy Candy 

All the fun with none of the sugar. Celebrate Easter without compromising on taste with our sugar-free Easter taffy. They’re the ideal treat for anyone managing dietary restrictions or just looking to cut down on sugar. 

What Makes Our Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Unique?

  • Whipped to Perfection: Our sugar-free taffy is as soft and chewy as the original, thanks to our whipping process.
  • Flavorful Variety: From fruity favorites like Sugar-Free Fresh Strawberry to creamy classics like Sugar-Free Very Vanilla, every bite is packed with deliciousness.
  • Gluten-Free Goodness: Crafted so no one gets excluded from the fun.
  • Easter-Ready Packaging: Each candy is individually wrapped making it perfect for baskets, parties, or as thoughtful gifts.

A History of Sweetness: The Taffy Shop Story

At Taffy Shop, we’ve been in the business of spreading smiles and cheer since 1998. The seed we planted then on the shores of the Great Salt Lake has blossomed into a beloved brand with over 85 gourmet taffy flavors. 

We started our sweet journey pulling taffy by hand. Fast forward some years and we’ve become pioneers in delicious, chewy taffy candy. A lot has changed since we began but what will never change is our commitment to quality and customer delight. Today, our taffy is whipped—not pulled— to craft the best taffy and bring a little joy to every bite. 

How to Enjoy Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Candy

  • Easter Gifting: Make your Easter festivities extra joyful with our taffy candy. You can even tuck these individually wrapped pieces into eggs for a fun Easter egg hunt surprise.
  • Party Favors: There’ll be smiles all around with these guilt-free goodies at Easter brunch or gatherings.
  • Daily Treats: Keep a stash on hand for whenever you’re craving something sweet.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Candy

What makes this taffy sugar-free?

Our sugar-free taffy is sweetened with maltitol, a sugar alternative that provides the same delicious taste so you won't have to miss out on sweet moments.

Does sugar-free taffy taste different?

Not at all! Our sugar-free taffy has the same amazing flavor and texture you love from our regular taffy.

Is sugar-free taffy safe for kids?

Yes! But like all good things, we recommend enjoying it in moderation to avoid any potential sensitivities to sugar substitutes.

How long does sugar-free taffy stay fresh?

When stored in a cool, dry place, our novelty taffy stays fresh for months, ensuring you can enjoy its delightful flavors at your own pace.

Can I order sugar-free taffy in bulk?

Absolutely! You can put in a bulk order for events, and parties, or simply stocking up on your favorites.

Is sugar-free taffy gluten-free?

Yes! Like all Taffy Shop products, our sugar-free taffy is 100% gluten-free.

Sweeten Your Easter With Taffy Shop

Bring joy, flavor, and fun to your Easter celebrations with Taffy Shop’s Sugar-Free Easter Taffy Candy Collection. Perfect for treating yourself or sharing with loved ones, our sugar-free taffy proves that you don’t need sugar to enjoy a little sweetness. Explore our collection today and find your new favorite flavor!

Explore Related Collections

We’ve got so much more taffy that you’ll love (because you’ve got great taste!) Check out our Lime Taffy Candy collection for something tart, our Vanilla Taffy Candy for a creamy classic, and our Easter Taffy Candy collection for something festive, but WITH sugar.