Skip to content

Time To Unlock The Magic!

You've made it past the velvet rope and into our VIP lounge! Welcome to the hush-hush world of our exclusive taffy flavors! 

Thank you for visiting our Secret Flavor Guide! You've gotten a sneak peek of some of our most exceptional concoctions in your sampler.

If you'd like to uncover even more secrets, continue scrolling down to discover the rest of our exclusive lineup. Plus, learn about the benefits of becoming a member of our Taffy of the Month Club and enjoy a special offer on your first purchase. Keep reading - the sweetness continues!

1st Order Deal: Only $15.99!

And...Taffy Club Members get free shipping on their first order and every order! 

The Secret Flavor Guide

Ready to crack the code? Use the list below to decipher the flavors included within your exclusive sampler pack.

Amoretti

Amoretti

Blackberry Crumble

Blackberry Crumble

Blueberry Jam

Blueberry Jam

Blueberry Muffin

Blueberry Muffin

Breafast Cereal

Breafast Cereal

Bubble Gum

Bubble Gum

Burnin' Love

Burnin' Love

Campfire S'mores

Campfire S'mores

Canadian Maple

Canadian Maple

Candy Canes

Candy Canes

Candy Corn

Candy Corn

Caribbean Butter Rum

Caribbean Butter Rum

Chili Mango Madness

Chili Mango Madness

Chocolate Haupia

Chocolate Haupia

Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon Santas

Cinnamon Santas

Cookies for Santa

Cookies for Santa

Amoretti

Cran Raspberry

Amoretti

Creamy Caramel

Amoretti

Creamy Eggnog

Fall Apple

Fall Apple

Fresh Mango

Fresh Mango

Fresh Squeezed OJ

Fresh Squeezed OJ

Frozen Hot Chocolate

Frozen Hot Chocolate

Huckleberry Marmalade

Huckleberry Marmalade

Indian Coconut Curry

Indian Coconut Curry

Japanese Strawberry Mochi

Japanese Strawberry Mochi

Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Lilikoi

Lilikoi

Light Green Pear

Light Green Pear

Limoncello

Limoncello

Madagascar Vanilla

Madagascar Vanilla

Maple Bacon

Maple Bacon

Neapolitan

Neapolitan

Pineapple Whip

Pineapple Whip

Pina Colada

Pina Colada

POG

POG

Prickly Pear

Prickly Pear

Raspberry Jam

Raspberry Jam

Red Licorice

Red Licorice

Spiced Pumpkin

Spiced Pumpkin

Spumoni

Spumoni

Strawberries 'N Cream

Strawberries 'N Cream

Strawberry Cheesycake

Strawberry Cheesycake

Thai Peanut

Thai Peanut

Curious How To Get Even More Exclusive Flavors...Every Month?

Join the Taffy of the Month Club Today to Enjoy Custom Flavors & Gourmet Taffy Whipped Every Month!

TOMC - Jan '25 Front.jpg__PID:b4e19776-e2e3-4808-a223-bc200cafb8cd

Your Secret Limited Time Offer

First Month $15.99

with free shipping on every order!

$17.99/mo after first order; shipping always free

For 99.9% of people, Christmas is once a year. For you, it’s every month! Join the Taffy Club and we’ll send you a 14oz bag of curated taffy each month.

Your shipment includes 5 themed gourmet flavors so mm-mm good, your taste buds will do the moonwalk. Just picture it! The dazzling excitement of opening each wrapper. The buzzing thrill of discovering delicious new flavors.

I've Seen Enough, Sign Me Up!

Introducing February's
Happy Valentine's Day Mix

Buckle up, taffy lover! This month’s mix will tickle your taste buds in all the right ways.

Get your hand's on this month's one-of-a-kind mix, featuring:

TS-SEPT-TOMC-Front.png__PID:b6ab8dd2-a398-45b1-a23e-0c41de796ff7
TS-SEPT-TOMC-Back.png__PID:beb6ab8d-d2a3-4865-b162-3e0c41de796f

Delight is guaranteed. Sharing is optional.

Your Taffy Of The Month Club Membership Perks

We'll treat you like royalty, without the whole beheading thing

Do you like being pampered? As a member, you get the “King Charles” treatment. Imagine having your cheese and biscuits served at a precise temperature at the end of meals while your staff keeps a warming tray nearby (we’re not making this up!).

Get ready to be spoiled. Your monthly mix of taffy comes with a handful of perks:

Free Shipping On ALL Orders

For this order and any other orders placed on TaffyShop.com. Because royalty doesn’t pay for shipping. End of story.

Never-Released-Before Flavors

Your personal chefs creating custom taffy just for you. It’s only fitting. Each monthly batch includes 14oz of taffy and a minimum of 2 custom flavors no one else has access to.

Happiness Guaranteed

We’ll make sure you have an imperial experience from start to finish. If not, off with our heads! Email us at taffyclub@taffyshop.com and we’ll make it right.

The World's Best Saltwater Taffy

Our mouth-watering taffy is whipped for 24 hours straight. The result? It’s softer than a pillow stuffed with Shih Tzus, and creamier than a leprechaun’s lucky charm milkshake! 

I'm Ready To Claim My Throne!

Here's How It Works

You sign up. We ship monthly. You munch on the world’s softest taffy and give yourself a hug because - wowee - who would’ve thought a taffy subscription could fill your life with such pizazz?

1.

Start

Become a Taffy Club member. The rest is easy. Actually joining is easy too, so don’t wait for the mermaid to sing you a song - sign up now and buckle up your taste buds!

2.

Ship

Once you’ve joined, we’ll process and ship your first order. Your mix includes at least 2 themed flavors no one else has access to. Can you say Yippee Kay Yay?

3.

Snack

We've shipped. You've received. Now it's time to rip open your gourmet bag and dig into your chew-perb salt water taffy.

Let's Go!

Taffy Reimagineered

We make the world's softest gourmet salt water taffy. Whipped, not pulled. Flavors galore for the sweet-toothed, the adventurous, the bold, the playful, the curious, the happy-go-lucky, the slightly goofy, and anyone in between.

It’s happiness in your pocket. A warm fuzzy feeling you can access on demand.

A New Kind of Nostalgia In Every Bite

It might look like taffy. It might smell like taffy. It might chew like taffy. But every piece is like a time machine for your senses, ready to jolt you right back into your happiest memories.

Playing hide and seek. Pretending the floor is lava. Or riding in the car on a rainy day, watching raindrops racing down the window, and then picking a winner. And the crowd goooes wiiiiiild!

Your next batch of sweet memories is just a taffy wrapper away.

Become A Taffy Club Member

You Have Questions, We Have Answers

Send Me Taffy!

Taffy That Stretches Your Smile

We LOVE our taffy. And so do our customers, who just can’t get enough of this soft, creamy, omg-I-cant-believe-this-is-taffy goodness.

Katie S.

Delicious. Delectable. I grew up in NJ and always had Jersey Shore Salt Water Taffy - these are better.

Ellyn M.

I've tried several different brands (taffy is one of my favorite candies), and this was by far the best.

Jan K.

Absolutely fantastic. I can't believe how good these are. Fantastic service and candy. I will definitely shop here again.

Let's Go!