Weird Candy Flavors: A Sweet Adventure for Your Tastebuds

Familiarity, nostalgia, simplicity—these are the reasons classic flavors will always reign supreme. Many of us grew up savoring vanilla, chocolate, and banana-flavored candy, each bite tied to cherished memories. Maybe it was the treat you enjoyed at family picnics or in your best friend’s backyard, taking a break from running under the sun. And if you were feeling playful, you might have even smushed two flavors together, creating a weird yet wonderful “super flavor.” Sweet, sweet memories we won’t soon forget.

But what happens when candy takes a walk on the wild side? Beyond the classics, there's a whole world of bold, bizarre, and unexpectedly delicious flavors waiting to shake up your sweet tooth.

From sweet and savory mashups to bold, unexpected twists, some flavors make you do a double take before taking a bite. Whether you’re curious, adventurous, or just looking for a fun treat to share with friends, these unusual candies prove that the world of sweets has no limits.

So buckle up, because we’re about to take you on a wild ride through some of the strangest and most unusual candy flavors that have ever graced the shelves. And, of course, we’ll dive into how Taffy Shop is leading the charge in offering these unique, quirky, and downright bizarre candy flavors!

11 Weird Taffy Flavors at Taffy Shop

If you've got an adventurous palate, Taffy Shop's got you. We have some unique candy flavors you’ll wanna try. This list includes the best of our collection of weird flavors. It features weird flavor pairings you never expected. Like honey and hot sauce???
Take a journey and discover candy flavors so weird, they work. Here are 11 weird taffy flavors that you absolutely have to try:

1. Unicorn Poop Candy

Flavor: Cake batter

Unicorn poop—yes, you read that right! This taffy flavor is a magical sweet flavor like cake batter. Like all our salt water taffy, it is extremely smooth and chewy. The creamy taste is soft and smooth. Whether you’re a fan of mythical creatures or just love a colorful and quirky treat, this one’s sure to please your sweet tooth. 
Indulge in the sweetness. Shop unicorn poop candy here.

2. Fo' Sizzle My Drizzle Salt Water Taffy

Flavor: Maple + Bacon + Pecan

This is the unexpected taffy twist you never knew you needed! Maple Bacon Pecan Salt Water Taffy combines the rich maple sweetness, crispy bacon’s smoky charm, and the nutty crunch of roasted pecans. The result? A deliciously chewy, melt-in-your-mouth delight. Who could say no to a sweet and savory snack that tastes this good?
Wanna try it? You can find maple bacon pecan candy here.

3. Noggin' On Heaven's Door Taffy

Flavor: Eggnog

Keeping a piece of the holiday mood going all year round sounds like a fantastic idea. Our Eggnog Salt Water Taffy is inspired by the festive, creamy, spiced drink. It offers the rich flavors of eggnog, including that dreamy hint of vanilla, nutmeg, and a dash of cinnamon. This classic salt water taffy is your holiday dream, made chewy.
Stay festive. Shop our eggnog candy here.

4. Norm's Hot Honey Taffy

Flavor: Hot Sauce Honey Candy

Interested in a little heat in your taffy? Hot sauce honey candy is the taffy flavor just for you. It brings the syrupy sweetness of honey with a spicy kick of hot sauce. It's so good, it will blow you away. It’s the perfect balance of sweet and spicy for those adventurous enough to try it. 
Here's the kick you were craving. Shop our hot sauce honey candy here.

5. Machew Pichew Taffy

Flavor: Flavor: Cream Soda + Bubble Gum + Champagne

Candy? Champagne? There’s two things you don't see together often, but boy, does it make for a tasty taffy. With cream soda, bubble gum, and champagne, this taffy tastes like a New Year's Day celebration. In fact, you might want to make sure you have a couple of these taffies next time you're celebrating. It’s the perfect treat to mark new beginnings, offering a mouthwatering combination that’ll make every moment sparkle.
Give your tastebuds something to celebrate. Shop our delightful champagne candy here.

6. Feel the Beet Taffy

Flavor: Beetroot Lemonade

Kids who hate their veggies? Not when it's Taffy Shop's beetroot lemonade candy. It's a little weird, a little earthy, a little tangy, and a lot delicious! Beetroot lemonade candy brings together the flavors of beetroot and lemonade in a sweet way that your taste buds will love. It’s a unique candy that’s bound to surprise your mouth. 
Love the sound of it? Find our unique beetroot lemonade candy here.

7. RootBRUH Taffy Candy

Flavor: Root Beer Barrel

Root beer float, anyone? Our root beer taffy takes you all the way back to old-school soda shop days. This delightful piece of taffy is everything you want from a taffy. It's a chewy, nostalgic, sweet experience. Kinda like sipping a root beer float on a sunny summer day! 
Ready for a throwback? Shop rootbeer candy here for the taste of nostalgia. Get it here.

8. Pumpy McPumpkin Face

Flavor: Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie

Pumpkin spice may be the drink of the season we all love. But pumpkin spice taffy? That's a treat you can enjoy all year round. This one brings together fall's superstar pumpkin with the classic chocolatey flavor of choc chip. This piece of taffy is a warm, comforting candy, perfect for those who can’t get enough of that cozy pumpkiny flavor. 
Enjoy the sweet magic of fall whenever you wish. Shop pumpkin spice candy here.

9. What's Poppin? Taffy

Flavor: Buttered Popcorn

Popcorn is crunchy. Taffy is smooth. Popcorn taffy sounds like a combo you'd try because your friend said, "Trust me. It's yummy"... Trust us, it's yummy. Popcorn taffy takes the familiar flavor of buttery popcorn and wraps it in sweet, chewy candy form. It’s a fun, light-hearted treat that combines the best of both worlds.
Have a taste of the movie theatre. Shop our popcorn candy here.

10. Pterodactyl Ptaffy

Flavor: Breakfast Cereal

Rise and shine, cereal lovers. With the goodness of sweet and crunchy morning cereal, our breakfast cereal candy captures that flavor you like to wake up to (or snack on) and transforms it into a chewy, delicious treat. It’s a perfect way to start the day—or satisfy your cravings later! 
Brighten your day. Shop our breakfast cereal candy here.

11. Kind of a Big Dill Taffy

Flavor: Dill Pickle

It’s surprising what a savory twist can do for your sweet tooth. Get that tangy, slightly sour punch from our unique dill pickle-flavored candy. Is it a little unexpected for a taffy? Maybe. here. But for the boldest taste buds, it's a deliciously daring delight. Be daring. Shop our dill pickle candy here. 

Why Taffy Shop’s Weird Flavors are a Must Try

We make all our taffy with the best of the best ingredients. We're a family-owned business committed to bringing you smiles in the shape of taffy. Every single piece is carefully wrapped in our photo-worthy wrappers and packaged in a handy resealable bag. Our taffy candy stands out for so many great reasons. Here are a few:

• Whipped, Not Pulled: Traditional taffy is pulled and stretched, creating a denser, chewier texture. At Taffy Shop, we whip our taffy to create a fluffier, melt-in-your-mouth experience.
  
• Over 75 Flavors: We have the classics, fruity, creamy, sour taffy, and even weird flavors. There's something for everyone.
  
• Top-Quality Ingredients: We use only the best ingredients, including real salt and premium flavoring, to ensure every piece of taffy delivers the perfect balance of taste and texture.

Frequently Asked Questions About Weird Candy Flavors

Is Taffy Shop’s candy made with sugar?

Yes. Just like many traditional candies, Taffy Shop’s weird candy flavors have sugar. But the real fun comes from the mix of sweet and savory, or sweet and spicy, giving your tastebuds a thrilling ride with every bite.

If you’re watching your sugar intake, we have a delicious selection of sugar-free candy. It still has that same great taste, just minus the sugar.

Can I order Taffy Shop candy online?

Absolutely! You can easily order Taffy Shop’s unusual candy online and have it delivered to your doorstep. Whether you’re craving pumpkin spice candy or root beer candy, there’s a bag ready for you to enjoy.

Wrapping It Up: Go On a Weird Taste Adventure

We've come a long way from classic vanilla, chocolate, and banana taffy. The world of candy is bigger, bolder, and weirder than ever. Make sure you check out our novelty taffy candy for these amazing taffy and more.