How Is Salt Water Taffy Made? A Journey from Sugar to Chewy Bliss

Boardwalk strolls, beachside vacations, and after-school afternoons with your closest neighborhood buddies. What do these things have in common? Salt water taffy was always the trusty snack to accompany these fond memories.

Taffy candy has been a staple in your journey, but have you ever stopped and wondered: ‘How is this heavenly snack made?’ And equally important, does it actually contain salt water? As taffy lovers here at Taffy Shop, we're all about the process of making the best taffy candy, so we're the right people to tell you all about it. Here's the sweet magic behind this iconic treat.

Key Takeaways

• Traditional salt water taffy doesn’t contain salt water—despite what the name suggests. At Taffy Shop, we do things a little differently. (Spoiler: the secret’s in the salt)
  
• Traditional ingredients include sugar, cornstarch, and other ingredients. The mix is cooked into a hot sugar mixture before the pulling process.
  
• Air bubbles are incorporated into the taffy, making it light and chewy instead of dense and sticky.
  
• David Bradley and an ocean swell may have been responsible for the name, but the candy’s roots go back to Atlantic City.
  
• At Taffy Shop, we use a unique whipping process instead of traditional pulling, making our taffy lighter and melt-in-your-mouth delicious.
  

What Is Salt Water Taffy?

Salt water taffy is, without a doubt, one of the most classic American candies. It's a classic chewy candy known for its stretchy texture and deliciously sweet flavors.

Now, here are some sweet facts to satisfy your curiosity. They’ll come in handy for trivia night or help you become a well-informed sweet tooth!

• Where was salt water taffy made? Taffy was invented in Atlantic City, New Jersey. It was famously sold on boardwalks.
  
• When was salt water taffy made? The sugary treat, as we know it, was made in the late 19th century and quickly became a fun seaside resort staple.
  
• Who made salt water taffy? Well, some people credit David Bradley while others beg to differ. It's still up for debate who exactly invented salt water taffy.
  
• Why is it called salt water taffy? There are a few stories, but the most popular legend involves a candy store flooded by a high tide from the Atlantic Ocean, soaking all the taffy. When a little girl asked for a piece, the shop owner jokingly called it “salt water taffy,” and the name stuck!
  

So, let's get into the process and answer the question: How is salt water taffy made?

Ingredients: How is Salt Water Taffy Made?

Despite its name, most recipes don’t actually include salt—ours does though. We use real, high-quality sea salt and that’s what gives ours that unmatched flavor. 

Salt water taffy has been around for a very long time, and the recipes vary quite a bit now. The most important ingredients to making the classic candy often include these ingredients:

• Sugar – The base of all things sweet.
  
• Corn syrup – Makes the taffy candy smooth and helps prevent crystallization.
  
• Evaporated milk – Also helps get that extra light bite.
  
• Cornstarch – Helps thicken the mixture.
  
• Salt – Just a tiny bit!
  
• Flavorings – From chocolate to peppermint, lemon to banana, or any other flavors you love.
  
• Food coloring – Because taffy is best when it's bright and fun.
  
• Wax Paper - This is to wrap the candy.
  

The Traditional Taffy-Making Process

The process starts with heating the ingredients over medium heat in a large copper kettle until they form a hot sugar mixture. Here’s how it works:

Step 1: Boiling the Mixture

Firstly, you'd gather your sugar, corn syrup, and butter and then melt them together over medium heat, reaching 250-253°F (cue the candy thermometer!). This is the perfect state to get the taffy candy stretchy when it cools.

Step 2: Cooling on a Greased Cookie Sheet

Once the mixture is cooked, you pour it onto a greased cookie sheet or parchment paper, where it'll sit to cool.

Step 3: Pulling the Taffy

When the mixture cools slightly, it’s time to pull taffy. This is the most popular part of the traditional taffy-making process -pulling. It's also what gives the candy its signature chewiness.

Pulling stretches the taffy and incorporates air bubbles, making it lighter and softer. Traditionally, this was done by hand, but today, pulling machines handle the job in candy factories.

Step 4: Cutting and Wrapping

Once the taffy reaches the perfect consistency, it’s rolled into long ropes, cut into bite-sized pieces, and wrapped in wax paper to stay fresh.

Our Process at Taffy Shop

We want to bring back sweet, sweet memories, and taffy is our way to do it. At Taffy Shop, we're not only reimagining nostalgia— we're taking the best of tradition and adding a delicious twist. Wanna know our secret? While many taffy makers pull their taffy, we do things a little differently, and that's what makes us stand out.

What Makes Taffy Shop’s Taffy So Delicious?

Our taffy candy is not pulled, it's whipped. The difference is that when you pull taffy, you get a harder, denser, shinier candy. Whipping, on the other hand, introduces air into the mix. This transforms the texture completely, resulting in an airy, light candy.

Our whipping process means our taffy is always smoother than smooth, softer than soft, and yummier than yum. We aim for the perfect melt-in-your-mouth texture that keeps taffy lovers coming back.

Our Fun Flavors

At Taffy Shop, we have so many fun taffy flavors. We're always coming up with more exciting combinations that'll wow your taste buds. We offer over 85 gourmet taffy flavors, including familiar classics that take you back to grandma's house during the holidays. We've also got some unexpected flavors that'll quickly turn into your new favorite treat. There's a mouthwatering goodie for all tastes. Here are just a few sugary fan favorites:

• Fresh Strawberry Taffy - Sweet and fruity like ripened strawberries.
  
• Birthday Cake Cake Taffy - A rich vanilla taffy flavor that tastes like a celebration.
  
• Black Licorice Taffy - A sophisticated treat that a licorice lover will enjoy.
  
• Caramel Apple Taffy - An irresistible combination of crispy apple and salted caramel.
  
• Peanut Butter Taffy - A 100% nut-free smooth and creamy flavor with a yummy nutty taste.
  
• Lemon Taffy - A delightful flavor that tastes like lemon meringue pie.
  
• Chocolate Taffy - Its rich and creamy flavor like chocolate.
  

We have so many scrumptious taffy flavors for you to check out. Browse our salt water taffy flavors to discover irresistible taffy candies that'll have you hooked.

Strawsome Taffy

Strawberry Flavored Taffy

5.0 out of 5 stars

Shop Now

Our True To Life Ingredients

It's not magic, and it's no secret. To make the best taffy, you have to use the best ingredients. We mix up high-quality ingredients like real eggs, sea salt, and pure coconut oil to make our taffy. What we don't have in our taffy is gluten, soy, or peanuts. Even our manufacturing facility is free of common allergens. You know what that means: more people can enjoy our delightful taffy and its delicious flavors without worry.

The Taffy Shop Story

Taffy Shop has been spreading smiles for over 20 years. We're a family-owned business, and we couldn't be more proud to offer our handcrafted taffy to you. We make our taffy candy in small batches to make sure you're getting the freshest taffy every time.
We're not like mass-produced taffy companies. No way. Our chewy candy is made with premium ingredients and care. Each chew bite you take is a flavor-packed memory designed to bring joy and a little seaside magic to your day.

Learn the Art of Taffy Making with Taffy Shop

Wanna bring out your candy creativity? At Taffy Shop, we’re excited to offer you the Taffyology Experience. It's a comprehensive taffy-making class where you can learn how to make your very own salt water taffy. Our 1h30m sessions are a sugar-packed experience that candy lovers would hate to miss. 

In our hands-on sessions, you’ll get to:

• Learn a little more about the history and science of salt water taffy.
  
• Get sticky with your own batch of Taffyology Taffy Making Kit.
  
• Discover the difference between pulling and whipping taffy first-hand.
  
• Walk away with your very own handmade taffy.
  

Join us at Taffy Shop and spice up date night, liven up team-building at the office, or bond with your friends while you create a sugary masterpiece together! 
Make your booking for the Taffyology Experience today.

Frequently Asked Questions About Salt Water Taffy

What ingredients do you use in your Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy?

Our Sugar-Free Salt Water Taffy is made with sugar substitutes like maltitol syrup to get the sugar taste without sugar. We also use coconut oil, sea salt, egg whites, evaporated milk, artificial flavor, natural flavor, malic acid, and artificial color.

Our sugar-free taffy candy still has the light, airy taste you love from our regular candy, minus the sugar.

What’s the difference between salt water taffy and regular taffy?

Salt water taffy is softer and lighter due to its unique process of adding more air into the mixture. The aeration process captures tiny bubbles in the candy, transforming it into a lighter textured candy. Other taffies (like Laffy Taffy) are denser and stickier. We also use real sea salt to give our taffy extra flavor.

Time to Enjoy Some Taffy!

So now you know the sweet science of how salt water taffy is made! From Atlantic City and throughout the country, its traditional roots to modern whipping techniques, taffy in all textures and flavors has captured hearts for over a century.

It's the tasty treat to satisfy your sweet tooth, whatever the occasion. So, if you're looking for cool new flavors, Taffy Shop has all the taffy you need. Browse our collection of delicious salt water taffy today. You have over 70 different flavors to try, so go ahead, start today, and —unwrap the chewy goodness.

Because some things never go out of style… and taffy is one of them.